Est. 1937  ·  Waterport, New York

A Family Cottage
on the Oak Orchard River

★ 4.95 on Airbnb ★ 10/10 on VRBO 143 reviews
Direct River Access Walk to the Oak Orchard
2 Bedrooms Sleeps 5 comfortably
Wrap-Around Deck Covered grill & dining
5 Min to Lake Ontario Beaches, marina, parks

See It for Yourself

View All Photos
Deck lounging area with Adirondack chairs looking toward the river

The Deck Is Why People Come Back

The wrap-around deck looks out through mature trees toward the river. Covered section with a grill and dining table. Most guests spend more time out here than inside.

Full Cottage Details
Living room with wood stove and comfortable seating

Updated. Original Character Kept.

Hardwood floors, working wood stove, full kitchen, Smart TV with YouTube TV, WiFi, and A/C. Queen bedroom, twin bedroom, and a couch that sleeps one more. Everything you need for a few days on the river.

View Amenities

143 Reviews. Nearly Perfect Ratings.

4.95/5
Airbnb · 107 reviews
10/10
VRBO · 36 reviews
★★★★★

"This place is an absolute gem. We came for the salmon run and couldn't have asked for a better home base. The river access is incredible and the cottage had everything we needed."

Fishing trip guest

October 2025

★★★★★

"Perfect family weekend. The kids loved exploring the woods and the deck is amazing. It feels private and tucked away but you're close to everything. We'll be back."

Family getaway guest

July 2025

★★★★★

"We've stayed here three times now. It's clean, well-maintained, and the host is incredibly responsive. The wrap-around deck is our favorite part — you just sit and watch the trees."

Returning guest

August 2025

Ready to Get Away?

Book your stay at Crooked Creek and experience the Oak Orchard River for yourself.

Check Availability